I've seen a number of posts regarding the question:
From my experiences with all 6 grinding wheels (SG, SB, SJ, DC, DF, & DE), I have come to believe that a better question is
I find that I use the diamond grinding wheels for harder metals like
These were previously sharpened using the SB grindstone.
And, I use the SG grindstone for almost everything else.
So the question to be answered is,
If the tools to be sharpened are harder steels, then go with either the diamond grinding wheels or the SB grindstone. Do note that the SB grindstone can be regraded, so I believe it is comparable to the DF + DE grinding wheels. And the SB is lower cost than the two diamond wheels.
If you are not needing to sharpen tools with such hardness, go with the SG grindstone.
If you need both, my advice is to start with the SG & SB grindstones. Eventually, the SB grindstone will wear down and need to be replaced. Then you can consider getting the diamond grinding wheels.
I welcome thoughts and feedback on experiences from others.
Should one invest in diamond grinding wheels or go with the SG grindstone?
From my experiences with all 6 grinding wheels (SG, SB, SJ, DC, DF, & DE), I have come to believe that a better question is
Should one invest in diamond grinding wheels or go with the SB grindstone?
I find that I use the diamond grinding wheels for harder metals like
- Wood turning tools (usually HSS)
- Carbide inserts for wood and metal lathe tools
- Drill bits
These were previously sharpened using the SB grindstone.
And, I use the SG grindstone for almost everything else.
So the question to be answered is,
What do you plan to sharpen?
If the tools to be sharpened are harder steels, then go with either the diamond grinding wheels or the SB grindstone. Do note that the SB grindstone can be regraded, so I believe it is comparable to the DF + DE grinding wheels. And the SB is lower cost than the two diamond wheels.
If you are not needing to sharpen tools with such hardness, go with the SG grindstone.
If you need both, my advice is to start with the SG & SB grindstones. Eventually, the SB grindstone will wear down and need to be replaced. Then you can consider getting the diamond grinding wheels.
I welcome thoughts and feedback on experiences from others.