Setting a tool in an Eclipse style honing guide for a given bevel angle is really quick: shove the tool in, offer it up to a pre-made stop, tighten the guide. Even without a pre-made stop, using one of these edge distance gauge things things makes it very quick.
By contrast, setting up the SE-77 square edge jig requires using the WMB-200 and squinting to see whether the angle is right while you tweak the support bar up and down. That felt to me like a bit of a faff, so I thought I'd figure out the maths that gives the protrusion for a given support bar offset. It ended up being quite complicated, but I like maths, so that's okay
Anyway, what that ends up with is the ability to set the support bar to a particular distance from the wheel (which is easy with a setting tool a la Micha Schmid and Keld Petersen) and then set the tool protrusion in much the same way as you can with an Eclipse honing guide.
Unfortunately, it's not quite as simple as that as the wheel diameter and tool thickness have an effect. For most practical uses, small changes in wheel diameter can be ignored, as can tool thickness changes so I think it's okay.
Anyway, having done all the maths, I thought I'd turn it into a calculator and stick it on my website (so it runs in a browser and doesn't need any spreadsheets or other software installed on your PC).
If anyone is interested, the calculator is here:
https://www.cgtk.co.uk/woodwork/calculators/tormeksquareedge
There's also one for manual honing guides here:
https://www.cgtk.co.uk/woodwork/calculators/honingguide
I'd welcome any comments
Screenshot:
You cannot view this attachment.
By contrast, setting up the SE-77 square edge jig requires using the WMB-200 and squinting to see whether the angle is right while you tweak the support bar up and down. That felt to me like a bit of a faff, so I thought I'd figure out the maths that gives the protrusion for a given support bar offset. It ended up being quite complicated, but I like maths, so that's okay
Anyway, what that ends up with is the ability to set the support bar to a particular distance from the wheel (which is easy with a setting tool a la Micha Schmid and Keld Petersen) and then set the tool protrusion in much the same way as you can with an Eclipse honing guide.
Unfortunately, it's not quite as simple as that as the wheel diameter and tool thickness have an effect. For most practical uses, small changes in wheel diameter can be ignored, as can tool thickness changes so I think it's okay.
Anyway, having done all the maths, I thought I'd turn it into a calculator and stick it on my website (so it runs in a browser and doesn't need any spreadsheets or other software installed on your PC).
If anyone is interested, the calculator is here:
https://www.cgtk.co.uk/woodwork/calculators/tormeksquareedge
There's also one for manual honing guides here:
https://www.cgtk.co.uk/woodwork/calculators/honingguide
I'd welcome any comments
Screenshot:
You cannot view this attachment.