My chisels and plane irons are all high carbon steel. Most are oder than I am (74).
With no disrespect toward modern tools, my venerable tools have always served me well.
Whenever I read posts like this, I am curious (not critical) about how many tools are invoved and in need of major sharpening. Ideally, much work can be done with three or four planes and about the same number of bench chisels. In the online classes, the Tormek instructors freqently refresh the SG frequently (around once per minute) with the stone grader. From the standpoint of cost effectiveness, in my opinion, the clear winner is a well maintained SG. Admittedly, the initial reshaping/sharpening will take longer than with harder grinding wheels.
If cost is no object, by all means go for the harder, more expensive wheels. I realize sharpening is somewhat of an enjoyable luxury for any of us, myself included. I am merely presenting the option of proceeding a little slower at lower cost.
Ken
With no disrespect toward modern tools, my venerable tools have always served me well.
Whenever I read posts like this, I am curious (not critical) about how many tools are invoved and in need of major sharpening. Ideally, much work can be done with three or four planes and about the same number of bench chisels. In the online classes, the Tormek instructors freqently refresh the SG frequently (around once per minute) with the stone grader. From the standpoint of cost effectiveness, in my opinion, the clear winner is a well maintained SG. Admittedly, the initial reshaping/sharpening will take longer than with harder grinding wheels.
If cost is no object, by all means go for the harder, more expensive wheels. I realize sharpening is somewhat of an enjoyable luxury for any of us, myself included. I am merely presenting the option of proceeding a little slower at lower cost.
Ken